1207

A "Mistake" Harvey Harris Ingot, Gold Hill, NT

Currency:USD Category:Coins & Paper Money / Ingots Start Price:1,250.00 USD Estimated At:2,500.00 - 5,000.00 USD
A  Mistake  Harvey Harris Ingot, Gold Hill, NT
SOLD
2,600.00USDto b***9+ buyer's premium (507.00)
This item SOLD at 2014 Sep 14 @ 14:27UTC-7 : PDT/MST
If you want to see an enlarged image, click on the thumbnail image in the lower left of the main image.
You can download a higher resolution image by clicking on the title below the enlarged image.
You can request extra images to be added by contacting HWAC at uwe@fhwac.com or by calling 775-851-1859
1 x 2", Internal Revenue Tax punch at top center, Three stars above. 3.30 ozs/ G976/ S021/ $5.59/ FINE.  Irregular wavy line pattern around obverse and reverse. Blank reverse. High polish. This silver ingot was made to be a presentation ingot. It is very highly polished on both sides prior to punching, as well as fancily engraved along the edges front and back prior to punching. It dates from the period 1863 to about 1868, based upon the federal Tax Stamp (punch). But there is much to learn from this ingot, which I don't believe has seen public record.

First, the engravings along the outside edges of both sides are indicative of Assayer Harvey Harris, though at least one Weigand ingot has similar traits. Second, the ingot engraving was never completed. There is a reason: Comstock ingots are usually reported with the higher value first, which is silver. Thus the value reported would have been silver, then gold. Here, the assayer marking the ingot made a mistake, and put "G" for gold on top, with the attendant silver fineness of 976. If this were indeed 976 fine gold, the color of the ingot would be gold. It is clearly silver color, thus the number placement is reversed. The "S" for silver under the gold fineness is 021 fine, which matches very closely the average Comstock gold content for these little silver ingots. Thus the fineness is reversed. This is verified by the total dollar value of the ingot ($5.59), which only matches a silver fineness of 976. Once this mistake was realized, the maker had to start over, and would have discarded this ingot. One could speculate that the ingot was made in 1863, and that assayer Harris got confused after having worked on gold so much at his Marysville office, and perhaps was just back to Gold Hill after a trip to his Marysville office.City: Gold HillCounty: State: NVDate: