1253

J.L. Polhemus Counterstamped 1856-S $20 Gold Piece, S.S. Central America Treasure [146607]

Currency:USD Category:Coins & Paper Money / US Coins - Gold Start Price:10,000.00 USD Estimated At:20,000.00 USD and UP
J.L. Polhemus Counterstamped 1856-S $20 Gold Piece, S.S. Central America Treasure [146607]
SOLD
36,000.00USD+ (7,200.00) buyer's premium + applicable fees & taxes.
This item SOLD at 2022 Dec 03 @ 17:54UTC-8 : PST/AKDT
SHIPPING & HANDLING: The customer is responsible for all shipping and packaging charges. We offer shipping service as a convenience to our buyers. Items are not shipped until the invoice and shipping charges are completely paid. Shipping costs will be calculated and billed separately after your items have been paid for. Purchases will be shipped via our approved, insured carriers: FedEx, UPS, USPS or DHL. Pick up is available from our Reno office, once you have received your invoice post auction
Counterstamped US twenty-dollar gold piece, 1856-S, recovered from the S.S. Central America shipwreck. Certified and encapsulated in plastic by PCGS along with "ONE PINCH" of coarse gold dust also recovered from the shipwreck site. PCGS annotation reads // 1856-S $20 / PCGS / AU58 / No Serif, High Right S / Brunk P-563 / J.L. Polhemus //. The counterstamp is nicely centered above the eagle on the reverse of the coin. The full counterstamp states the location precisely, "J. L. Polhemus / Druggist /190 J. St. Cor. 7th. / Sacramento, Cal." with a charming tiny mortar & pestle in the middle of the stamp, symbolizing the druggist's trade. Reverse of the label has the signature of Bob Evans, chief scientist and historian for the recovery project and // I certify this / coin and gold dust / were recovered from / the S.S. Central / America. / 670708.58/35672241 //.

John L. Polhemus, was a colorful character and Gold Rush-era druggist in Sacramento, California. Polhemus counter stamped many U.S. and foreign coins then circulating in early California. It is said a coin never passed through his Sacramento drug store without being counter stamped. He was born in New York City in 1825 and arrived in California at the very height of the "Days of '49." By 1850, he had opened his apothecary, living and working in Sacramento until his death in 1866. Polhemus was a prolific advertiser, so much so that one would think he was the major player in the apothecary business in the Sacramento region. From his business at 196 J Street (1851), he sold drugs and medicines and distributed a different form of business or "calling" card -- he counterstamped coins. His directory advertisements were everywhere -- and so were his counterstamped coins.

Perhaps 100 of Polhemus counterstamped silver coins are known today. They are known in French, Spanish and American coinage, though the smaller denominations are more prevalent. Gold counter stamped Polhemus coins are exceptionally rare, with perhaps four to five known inclusive of all denominations. There are a few silver fakes out there too easy to spot -- they have rounded letters instead of the sharp cornered serifs seen in this outstanding example. Polhemus counterstamps are listed on p249-250 of Gregory G. Brunk's book, Merchant and Privately Countermarked Coins (World Exonumia Press, 2003), as well as in Russ Rulau's book on nineteenth century tokens.
The early apothecaries of the West Coast were quite a group. In San Francisco, the Lefevre family had more than three different locations that served the "Ladies of the night." Famous landscape artist William Keith even tried his hand at being an apothecary before starting a life in art -- first as a sketch artist for documents, then as a landscape artist whose paintings today sell for significant sums. This was the world of which Polhemus played an important part.

The counterstamp transforms the coin into a true time capsule, giving it a specific California story as well as the shipwreck story:

Imagine a Gold Rush miner--either about to head out into the Mother Lode goldfields to try his luck, or returning to town after striking it rich--coming in to visit this very popular druggist & California pioneer. The miner passes this gold coin across the counter to Polhemus to pay for merchandise. Then Polhemus, expert marketer that he was, brands the coin, permanently connecting it to his store. And then the coin eventually finds its way to the "Ship of Gold," sinking with the ship in the hurricane and dropping 7,200 feet into the deep; a relic of the Gold Rush left, for eternity, to advertise a California drugstore from the bottom of the ocean.

Date: 1856-S
Country (if not USA):
State:
City:
Provenance: SS Central America Collection