J.M. Davis Private Collection Firearm and Artifact Auction

Auction Details

Introduction to the J.M. Davis Private Collection Firearm and Artifact Auction

J.M. Davis ran the Mason Hotel in Claremore, Oklahoma, for his entire career, from 1917 onward. From the age of seven in 1901 until 1965, he was an inveterate collector of all firearms, as well as artifacts reflecting history in Oklahoma and the Mississippi Valley region. To preserve his collection in perpetuity, he created the 40,000-square-foot J.M. Davis Arms & Historical Museum in Claremore, which is today managed by the State of Oklahoma. It is the largest firearms Museum in North America.

The museum is a must-see for any weapons collector, displaying an incredible amount and variety of weaponry and famous felon, outlaw, and law enforcement personality items from history.

Proceeds of this sale directly benefit the long-term care and maintenance of the Collection. None of the items in this sale are out of the current museum exhibit displays. Nearly all of the items have been stored away, out of public view, since at least 1965 (54 years!), long before the modern era when most of the well-written and researched reference and table-top books on antique firearms were published. As an example, none of these weapons were known to R. Larry Wilson, a prolific firearms writer and author of approximately 60 books on antique firearms, who as a young man and budding firearms scholar, worked for Colt about the time this part of the collection went into storage.

The sale hosts more than 2200, antique to modern (probably none more recent than 1965) firearms, swords, crossbows and knives. In addition, there is a large section of Americana, featuring Native American stone and pottery items, primarily from Oklahoma and the Mississippi Valley. Items of cultural significance that are not in the sale are designated for, or already transferred to, the Oklahoma State Museum.

Davis was also a button, badge, medal and pinback collector, and there are more than a thousand items in this category, mostly in like-kind groups.

The two-day preview prior to the sale is a must for any serious collector.
I
SHIPPING & HANDLING: Shipping and Handling cannot be estimated prior to invoicing, based on the size and weight of your purchase. All shipping is subject to a minimum charge of $19.00. If additional shipping and handling costs are required, the buyer will be reinvoiced for the balance due. Items are not shipped until the invoice is completely paid. Many buyers purchase a number of lots. Every effort will be made to include all lots in a single shipping charge calculated to cover the weight and size of the package(s). NOTE: Some shipments (of unusual size, dimension, or weight) may require sp...
Choose Your Layout > Switch to Grid View Switch to List View
Metropolitan Arms 51 Navy Pistol 1863 JMD-1123620950 - Metropolitan Arms 51 Navy Pistol 1863 JMD-11236
Holabird Western Americana Collections
Pistol, Metropolitan Arms, 51 Navy, Copy of Colt 1851 Navy Percussion revolver. In 1862. Colt Commissioned Metropolitan to make them in 1862 when Colt
Bidding Has Concluded
Estimate : 500.00 - 1,500.00
Sold to h********@.. for (900.00 + 225.00BP) = 1,125.00
 
Details...Bookmark
Mohawk Brand Pistol 1960s JMD-1131820951 - Mohawk Brand Pistol 1960s JMD-11318
Holabird Western Americana Collections
Pistol, Mohawk Brand, Percussion Pistol, Possibly replica SN: N/A, JMD Oval Tag: 10618, Condition: Very Good, >
Bidding Has Concluded
Estimate : 100.00 - 200.00
Sold to S**********1 for (50.00 + 12.50BP) = 62.50
 
Details...Bookmark
Moreita Pistol 1960s JMD-1125420952 - Moreita Pistol 1960s JMD-11254
Holabird Western Americana Collections
Pistol, Moreita, Non- gun replica of 1770s flintlock, ornate. SN: N/A, JMD Oval Tag: 563, Condition: Good, >
Bidding Has Concluded
Estimate : 50.00 - 100.00
Sold to C********s.. for (200.00 + 50.00BP) = 250.00
 
Details...Bookmark
NY Pistol 1850s JMD-1122120953 - NY Pistol 1850s JMD-11221
Holabird Western Americana Collections
This is a pistol marked " NY" model 1XL in .31 caliber from the 1850's. It must be a double action revolver because the hammer has no ...
Bidding Has Concluded
Estimate : 100.00 - 400.00
Sold to b********d.. for (500.00 + 110.00BP) = 610.00
 
Details...Bookmark
Patdrfge Pistol 1870's JMD-1123120954 - Patdrfge Pistol 1870's JMD-11231
Holabird Western Americana Collections
Pistol, Patdrfge, Cap gun toy Vintage. Experimental, Percussion Pistol. SN: N/A, JMD Oval Tag: 10876, Condition: Poor, >
Bidding Has Concluded
Estimate : 100.00 - 300.00
Sold to D******L for (275.00 + 60.50BP) = 335.50
 
Details...Bookmark
Philadelphia Pistol 1840s JMD-1121420955 - Philadelphia Pistol 1840s JMD-11214
Holabird Western Americana Collections
This is an original "Derringer" marked pistol. (Note the name Derringer with only one "R". Philadelphia, Pa. in .40 cal. and a 4...
Bidding Has Concluded
Estimate : 300.00 - 600.00
Sold to d*******f for (700.00 + 175.00BP) = 875.00
 
Details...Bookmark
Philadelphia Pistol 1840s JMD-1121620956 - Philadelphia Pistol 1840s JMD-11216
Holabird Western Americana Collections
This is a derringer pocket pistol in.41 caliber marked P (in a circle) Philadelphia. 2.5 in. barrel in good condition. SN: N/A, JMD Oval Tag: 9577, Co
Bidding Has Concluded
Estimate : 200.00 - 500.00
Sold to d*******f for (650.00 + 162.50BP) = 812.50
 
Details...Bookmark
Philadelphia Pistol 1850s JMD-1121820957 - Philadelphia Pistol 1850s JMD-11218
Holabird Western Americana Collections
This is a derringer pocket pistol marked "Philadelphia" in .40 cal. 2-in. barrel with a German silver inlay on the escutcheon side. SN: N/...
Bidding Has Concluded
Estimate : 200.00 - 500.00
Sold to d*******f for (1,500.00 + 375.00BP) = 1,875.00
 
Details...Bookmark
Philadelphia Pistol 1860s JMD-1127820958 - Philadelphia Pistol 1860s JMD-11278
Holabird Western Americana Collections
Pistol, Philadelphia, 3Ó-barrel, Derringer, checkered pistol grip. SN: N/A, JMD Oval Tag: 599, Condition: Good, >
Bidding Has Concluded
Estimate : 200.00 - 400.00
Sold to d*******f for (800.00 + 200.00BP) = 1,000.00
 
Details...Bookmark
Pistol 1640s JMD-1117320959 - Pistol 1640s JMD-11173
Holabird Western Americana Collections
This is a snap-haunch pistol of European origin that has been repaired in the Mediterranean area. Used aboard ships and may have seen duty in the merc
Bidding Has Concluded
Start Price : 50.00 | Estimate : 100.00 - 400.00
 
 
Details...Bookmark
Pistol 1790s JMD-1118520960 - Pistol 1790s JMD-11185
Holabird Western Americana Collections
This is a flintlock pistol in .58 caliber. Maker and origin unknown. About 20 in. long with a 16 in round barrel; in an unaltered state. It has a cast
Bidding Has Concluded
Estimate : 300.00 - 500.00
Sold to 8********l.. for (700.00 + 175.00BP) = 875.00
 
Details...Bookmark
Pistol 1790s JMD-1119320961 - Pistol 1790s JMD-11193
Holabird Western Americana Collections
This is a French contract military pistol in about .69 cal. The barrel is round 10 in. long and overall length is 18 in. Original flintlock condition
Bidding Has Concluded
Estimate : 100.00 - 400.00
Sold to 8********l.. for (900.00 + 225.00BP) = 1,125.00
 
Details...Bookmark
Pistol 1790s JMD-1127720962 - Pistol 1790s JMD-11277
Holabird Western Americana Collections
This little flintlock pistol is chambered for .60 cal. A real gem of a pocket pistol about 1790's. Black Powder, ramrod, engraved side plate. SN...
Bidding Has Concluded
Estimate : 100.00 - 400.00
Sold to d*******f for (750.00 + 187.50BP) = 937.50
 
Details...Bookmark
Pistol 1790s JMD-1138120963 - Pistol 1790s JMD-11381
Holabird Western Americana Collections
A flintlock pistol, octagon barrel. Left hand looks to be a marriage of parts., ramrod. SN: N/A, JMD Oval Tag: 1479, Condition: Fair, >
Bidding Has Concluded
Estimate : 100.00 - 400.00
Sold to D*****6 for (140.00 + 35.00BP) = 175.00
 
Details...Bookmark
Pistol 1820s JMD-1116120964 - Pistol 1820s JMD-11161
Holabird Western Americana Collections
This is a very beautiful flintlock dueling pistol; one of a pair? It is cased in European walnut and curiously without a ramrod. There would not be a
Bidding Has Concluded
Estimate : 500.00 - 1,500.00
Sold to 8********l.. for (1,000.00 + 250.00BP) = 1,250.00
 
Details...Bookmark
Pistol 1830s JMD-1127320965 - Pistol 1830s JMD-11273
Holabird Western Americana Collections
This is a flintlock pistol brass side plate and pistol butt. SN: N/A, JMD Oval Tag: 11347, Condition: Good, >
Bidding Has Concluded
Estimate : 100.00 - 400.00
Sold to 8********l.. for (700.00 + 175.00BP) = 875.00
 
Details...Bookmark
Pistol 1840s JMD-1115920966 - Pistol 1840s JMD-11159
Holabird Western Americana Collections
This is a percussion pistol that gives meaning to the name "hand cannon". A single-shot device trigger method unknown. About .73 cal. SN: ...
Bidding Has Concluded
Estimate : 100.00 - 400.00
Sold to d*******f for (425.00 + 106.25BP) = 531.25
 
Details...Bookmark
Pistol 1840s JMD-1116320967 - Pistol 1840s JMD-11163
Holabird Western Americana Collections
This is a percussion pistol at about .78 caliber. Thought to be a European made pistol dated 1768 on the lockplate. Which mean this pistol was origina
Bidding Has Concluded
Estimate : 100.00 - 400.00
Sold to 8********l.. for (275.00 + 68.75BP) = 343.75
 
Details...Bookmark
Pistol 1840s JMD-1116520968 - Pistol 1840s JMD-11165
Holabird Western Americana Collections
This pistol has an obscure hammer design where the percussion point may be internal to the gun. C. 1840-1860s. About .63 caliber. Maker and origin unk
Bidding Has Concluded
Estimate : 100.00 - 400.00
Sold to t****r for (3,000.00 + 750.00BP) = 3,750.00
 
Details...Bookmark
Pistol 1840s JMD-1117920969 - Pistol 1840s JMD-11179
Holabird Western Americana Collections
This is a percussion pistol of .62 cal. that may have started life as a military contract pistol judging by the lug on the bottom of the muzzle where
Bidding Has Concluded
Estimate : 100.00 - 400.00
Sold to 8********l.. for (250.00 + 62.50BP) = 312.50
 
Details...Bookmark
Pistol 1840s JMD-1118120970 - Pistol 1840s JMD-11181
Holabird Western Americana Collections
This is a percussion pistol of the 1840's period. In .58 caliber imported from Germany or Austria. About 14 in overall. SN: N/A, JMD Oval Tag: 4...
Bidding Has Concluded
Estimate : 100.00 - 400.00
Sold to a********j for (190.00 + 41.80BP) = 231.80
 
Details...Bookmark
Pistol 1840s JMD-1118320971 - Pistol 1840s JMD-11183
Holabird Western Americana Collections
This is thought to be a French percussion pistol in about .60 cal. Overall length is 20 in. in a European walnut stock. The barrel is octagon to round
Bidding Has Concluded
Estimate : 400.00 - 600.00
Sold to A*********s for (400.00 + 100.00BP) = 500.00
 
Details...Bookmark
Pistol 1840s JMD-1119120972 - Pistol 1840s JMD-11191
Holabird Western Americana Collections
This is a percussion pistol of an unknown maker. The gun is about 13 in. overall length with a 7 in. barrel. The barrel is bored to about .54 cal. and
Bidding Has Concluded
Estimate : 100.00 - 400.00
Sold to b********d.. for (375.00 + 82.50BP) = 457.50
 
Details...Bookmark
Pistol 1840s JMD-1119720973 - Pistol 1840s JMD-11197
Holabird Western Americana Collections
This is dug-up gun in non-working order. A Marston pistol with a 4 in. barrel about .32 caliber. In dig-up condition. SN: N/A, JMD Oval Tag: 8782, Con
Bidding Has Concluded
Estimate : 50.00 - 100.00
Sold to s******k for (600.00 + 132.00BP) = 732.00
 
Details...Bookmark
Pistol 1840s JMD-1120120974 - Pistol 1840s JMD-11201
Holabird Western Americana Collections
This is a percussion pistol of French origin 13 in. overall length and a 6 in. barrel octagon to round and no banded. It has a beautifully detailed po
Bidding Has Concluded
Estimate : 100.00 - 400.00
Sold to 8********l.. for (550.00 + 137.50BP) = 687.50
 
Details...Bookmark
Pistol 1840s JMD-1120520975 - Pistol 1840s JMD-11205
Holabird Western Americana Collections
This is a percussion pistol in about .34 cal. maker unknown. with a 12 in. barrel. Condition id fair. SN: N/A, JMD Oval Tag: 438, Condition: Fair, &...
Bidding Has Concluded
Estimate : 100.00 - 400.00
Sold to p**********f for (130.00 + 32.50BP) = 162.50
 
Details...Bookmark
Pistol 1840s JMD-1127120976 - Pistol 1840s JMD-11271
Holabird Western Americana Collections
Pistol, Percussion Cap Pistol, wood stock, brass trigger guard and pistol butt. SN: N/A, JMD Oval Tag: 1477, Condition: Good, >
Bidding Has Concluded
Estimate : 100.00 - 400.00
Sold to d*******f for (250.00 + 62.50BP) = 312.50
 
Details...Bookmark
Pistol 1840s JMD-1127920977 - Pistol 1840s JMD-11279
Holabird Western Americana Collections
This percussion pistol has a metal side plate and butt of the 1830's-1840's military contract rifles and pistols., No identifying markings. ...
Bidding Has Concluded
Estimate : 100.00 - 400.00
Sold to 8********l.. for (275.00 + 68.75BP) = 343.75
 
Details...Bookmark
Pistol 1840s JMD-1147920978 - Pistol 1840s JMD-11479
Holabird Western Americana Collections
Pistol, Percussion Pistol, Black Powder, ramrod. SN: N/A, JMD Oval Tag: 1448, Condition: Fair, >
Bidding Has Concluded
Estimate : 100.00 - 400.00
Sold to d*******f for (225.00 + 56.25BP) = 281.25
 
Details...Bookmark
Pistol 1840s JMD-1125520979 - Pistol 1840s JMD-11255
Holabird Western Americana Collections
Pistol, Percussion Pistol, wood grips. SN: 461, JMD Oval Tag: 11124, >
Bidding Has Concluded
Estimate : 100.00 - 400.00
Sold to H*********k for (800.00 + 200.00BP) = 1,000.00
 
Details...Bookmark
Pistol 1840s JMD-1132520980 - Pistol 1840s JMD-11325
Holabird Western Americana Collections
Pistol, .44 cal, Derringer Percussion Pistol SN: N/A, JMD Oval Tag: 409, >
Bidding Has Concluded
Estimate : 100.00 - 400.00
Sold to d*******f for (375.00 + 93.75BP) = 468.75
 
Details...Bookmark
Pistol 1840s JMD-1137720981 - Pistol 1840s JMD-11377
Holabird Western Americana Collections
A percussion pistol, octagon barrel, brass barrel wedge, blade front/leaf rear sight. SN: N/A, JMD Oval Tag: 1640, Condition: Good, >
Bidding Has Concluded
Estimate : 100.00 - 400.00
Sold to a********j for (170.00 + 37.40BP) = 207.40
 
Details...Bookmark
Pistol 1840s JMD-1137920982 - Pistol 1840s JMD-11379
Holabird Western Americana Collections
Pistol, Percussion Pistol, wood stock, SN: N/A, JMD Oval Tag: 1628, Condition: Good, >
Bidding Has Concluded
Estimate : 100.00 - 400.00
Sold to b********t.. for (65.00 + 16.25BP) = 81.25
 
Details...Bookmark
Pistol 1850s JMD-1119920983 - Pistol 1850s JMD-11199
Holabird Western Americana Collections
This is a percussion pocket pistol from the 1850's with a 4.5 in. barrel at .38 cal. Brass frame and barrel with a brass belt hook. A brass muzz...
Bidding Has Concluded
Estimate : 200.00 - 400.00
Sold to t******m for (375.00 + 82.50BP) = 457.50
 
Details...Bookmark
Pistol 1880's JMD-1141720984 - Pistol 1880's JMD-11417
Holabird Western Americana Collections
Pistol, 20 Gauge Percussion, cap SN: N/A, JMD Oval Tag: 1482, Condition: Good, >
Bidding Has Concluded
Estimate : 100.00 - 400.00
Sold to d*******f for (140.00 + 35.00BP) = 175.00
 
Details...Bookmark
Pistol 1880s (Belgian?)  JMD-1198920985 - Pistol 1880s (Belgian?) JMD-11989
Holabird Western Americana Collections
unknown manufacturer (Belgian?), 8mm/.22, fixed sights, no fore grip, cheek rest stock, metal butt plate. SN: N/A, JMD Oval Tag: 4228, Condition: Good
Bidding Has Concluded
Estimate : 100.00 - 400.00
Sold to s******0 for (190.00 + 41.80BP) = 231.80
 
Details...Bookmark
Pistol 1950s JMD-1119520986 - Pistol 1950s JMD-11195
Holabird Western Americana Collections
This is a copy of a Kentucky pistol built in the 1950's. About.40 cal.9 in. barrel with an Indian stamp on the stock. SN: N/A, JMD Oval Tag: 957...
Bidding Has Concluded
Estimate : 100.00 - 400.00
Sold to a********j for (75.00 + 16.50BP) = 91.50
 
Details...Bookmark
Pistol 1960s JMD-1138520987 - Pistol 1960s JMD-11385
Holabird Western Americana Collections
Percussion pistol, Black Powder, 16 in barrel, about .55 cal. A beautiful Damascus barrel with leaf scroll design. restocked SN: N/A, JMD Oval Tag: 27
Bidding Has Concluded
Estimate : 100.00 - 300.00
Sold to d*******f for (350.00 + 87.50BP) = 437.50
 
Details...Bookmark
Pistols, Lot of 3 JMD-1151120988 - Pistols, Lot of 3 JMD-11511
Holabird Western Americana Collections
Pistols, Lot of 3, PY Hahn 45 BB.177, Kalamazoo BB pistol, EM-SE Zella-Mehis, 5.5 mm, JMD Oval Tags: 9931, 9940 & 10865, CHECK YOUR LOCAL MUNICI...
Bidding Has Concluded
Estimate : 150.00 - 300.00
Sold to s********h for (700.00 + 175.00BP) = 875.00
 
Details...Bookmark
Pistols, Lot of 3 JMD-1151320989 - Pistols, Lot of 3 JMD-11513
Holabird Western Americana Collections
Pistols, Lot of 3, Morton H Harris Marksman.177, Ben Franklin, .177, Harris Marksman Repeater, .177, JMD Oval Tags: 4645, 4646 & 9945, Condition...
Bidding Has Concluded
Start Price : 75.00 | Estimate : 150.00 - 250.00
 
 
Details...Bookmark
Possibly British Pistol 1790s JMD-1126420990 - Possibly British Pistol 1790s JMD-11264
Holabird Western Americana Collections
Pistol, Possibly British, 12Ó-barrel, Flintlock Pistol. SN: N/A, JMD Oval Tag: 11360, Condition: Fair, >
Bidding Has Concluded
Estimate : 300.00 - 700.00
Sold to s******0 for (550.00 + 121.00BP) = 671.00
 
Details...Bookmark
Remington Arms Pistol 1870's JMD-1137520991 - Remington Arms Pistol 1870's JMD-11375
Holabird Western Americana Collections
Remington Arms percussion pistol, 8 in barrel in .32 cal., wood stock. SN: N/A, JMD Oval Tag: 4627, Condition: Good, >
Bidding Has Concluded
Start Price : 150.00 | Estimate : 300.00 - 500.00
 
 
Details...Bookmark
Remington Pistol 1860's JMD-1136520992 - Remington Pistol 1860's JMD-11365
Holabird Western Americana Collections
Pistol, Remington, 8.5 in, rolling block, blade front sight. leaf rear sight, checkered pistol grip. .22 cal. black-powder SN: N/A, JMD Oval Tag: 1496
Bidding Has Concluded
Estimate : 400.00 - 800.00
Sold to d*******f for (700.00 + 175.00BP) = 875.00
 
Details...Bookmark
Remington Pistol 1870s JMD-1132220993 - Remington Pistol 1870s JMD-11322
Holabird Western Americana Collections
Pistol, Remington.40 cal, 5.5" barrel., Pocket Pistol. SN: N/A, JMD Oval Tag: 11104, Condition: Good, >
Bidding Has Concluded
Estimate : 200.00 - 600.00
Sold to b********s for (700.00 + 175.00BP) = 875.00
 
Details...Bookmark
Remington Pistol 1880s JMD-1137220994 - Remington Pistol 1880s JMD-11372
Holabird Western Americana Collections
Pistol, Remington.30, 4"BARREL DERRINGER, SN: N/A, JMD Oval Tag: 8783, Condition: Poor/Parts Gun, >
Bidding Has Concluded
Estimate : 200.00 - 400.00
Sold to s******k for (60.00 + 13.20BP) = 73.20
 
Details...Bookmark
Remmington Pistol 1840s JMD-1120720995 - Remmington Pistol 1840s JMD-11207
Holabird Western Americana Collections
This is a pistol that is marked Remington Arms on the lock. Rare if not an experimental gun. SN: N/A, JMD Oval Tag: 9539, Condition: Good, >
Bidding Has Concluded
Estimate : 100.00 - 400.00
Sold to d*******f for (200.00 + 50.00BP) = 250.00
 
Details...Bookmark
S. Fitchburg 1893 Pistol 1890s JMD-1140820996 - S. Fitchburg 1893 Pistol 1890s JMD-11408
Holabird Western Americana Collections
Pistol, S. Fitchburg, 1893.22, Blade front/ adjustable notch rear sight, heavy target stock. SN: N/A, JMD Oval Tag: 1635, Condition: Very Good, >
Bidding Has Concluded
Estimate : 100.00 - 200.00
Sold to a********j for (100.00 + 22.00BP) = 122.00
 
Details...Bookmark
Smith & Wesson 1881 New Frontier Pistol 1881 JMD-1119820997 - Smith & Wesson 1881 New Frontier Pistol 1881 JMD-11198
Holabird Western Americana Collections
This is model 1881 New Frontier model Smith & Wesson 5 in. barrel chambered for .44 Russian. Double action break top. Original nickel with pearl...
Bidding Has Concluded
Start Price : 250.00 | Estimate : 500.00 - 800.00
 
 
Details...Bookmark
Smith & Wesson Pistol 1878 JMD-1128820998 - Smith & Wesson Pistol 1878 JMD-11288
Holabird Western Americana Collections
Pistol, Smith & Wesson.38 cal, Break top, single-action. SN: N/A, JMD Oval Tag: 6106, Condition: Poor, >
Bidding Has Concluded
Estimate : 200.00 - 500.00
Sold to C*******p for (225.00 + 49.50BP) = 274.50
 
Details...Bookmark
Spanish Percussion Pistol 1790s JMD-1125820999 - Spanish Percussion Pistol 1790s JMD-11258
Holabird Western Americana Collections
Spanish Flintlock large caliber boarding pistol with bell horn muzzle and .70 caliber bore. This pistol has a rare "BELT CLIP' for quick ac...
Bidding Has Concluded
Estimate : 300.00 - 700.00
Sold to 8********l.. for (550.00 + 137.50BP) = 687.50
 
Details...Bookmark